Group Discussion about "The Confessions of a Closet Catholic"

I found our discussion of this book very interesting. During our discussion, the main focus revolved around the portrayal of her parents as holocaust survivors. We had a good discussion about how she wanted to become a catholic and how her parents didnt like the fact that she was going to become a catholic when her grandparents were survivors of the holocaust.

i think it was a valuable disucssion because it opened my eyes to the fact that religion should be a person thing and no one should tell anyone what to do, even if it is sur parents.

an interesting point was the fact that her parents were so much against her becoming a catholic. they weren't into their religion so much and when she wanted to change her religion, they were so against it. it was also interesting that her grandmother was teh one person that was ok wiith her changing her religion and she was the person who was persecuted for the religion that she was. i think that it was interesting because she had to fight for her religion and then is ok with her granddaughter changing her religion. i think this emphasizes the fact taht relgion is a specific thing and shouldnt be forced on by anyone, even your parents.


our conversation outside of class was very interesting and i started looking at the book in a different light because of this meeting and discussion